Though I may, through this site (or, plausibly, in real life) come off as an insensitive prick, in fact, one of the few things I do well is empathize.

I don’t mean empathize as a synonym for sympathize, as in sharing someone else’s pain, but rather empathize in its purest sense, as in divining what other people are thinking, seeing things from other’s perspectives.

Tailoring a sales pitch on the fly to an audience, or searching out the perfect birthday gift, I’m grateful for this knack of putting myself in other people’s heads. But, like most things in life, it cuts both ways. Given the weight I put on what other people are thinking, I inevitably end up worrying about what other people are thinking of me.

This manifests itself in small, bizarre ways. Hearing female friends mock the wall-eyed guy at the end of the bar, for example, I’ll start to convince myself that perhaps I, too, have some horrible lazy eye and yet have never been told as much, even though it’s been secretly discussed for decades by friends and family behind my back.

I can usually cast aside such fears with a moment of reflection. I’ve seen countless pictures and videos of myself, and I’m sure that in at least the majority of them both of my eyes are looking more or less in the same direction.

Which leaves me to fixate instead on the things I hear and deduce on a regular basis. Some of them (“has anyone ever told you that you look like Matthew Broderick?”) don’t imply much beyond their surface content (I apparently look kind of like Matthew Broderick). But others I can’t keep from analyzing, from tearing apart for their loaded meaning.

One I’ve heard a lot recently is, “I’d be really, really curious to see who you end up marrying.” I’ve gotten this one, even in just the last month, more times than I can count. I think what this actually means is, “you seem like a judgmental asshole with bizarre and inscrutable dating criteria that make it nearly impossible for me to figure out your ‘type'”.

I must give off this impression in spades, because if I comment on liking a girl I’ve just met, friends usually react with, “really? I thought you didn’t go for [taller / shorter / thinner / curvier / blonde / brunette / smart / dumb / etc.] girls.” As I don’t think I say such things directly, I’m curious as to which obliquely snide comments or quirky reactions lead people to those strong impressions. Whatever it is, it’s powerful stuff. When people make such comments, there’s almost an air of helpful reminding. “Actually,” they seem to say, “despite the comment you just made to the contrary, I’m pretty sure you don’t like her after all.”

Hearing this from enough people, I start to suspect they’re right. Maybe I don’t like smart girls. Or stupid girls. Or tall blondes or short brunettes. I have absolutely no idea. Looking back through the wreckage of relationships past, I can’t quite make sensible patterns emerge.

Which is exactly the point. Perhaps the reason people so quickly rule out possibilities for me is that I’m so slow to categorically rule them out myself. My dating life, taken together, is an enigmatic, jumbled mess. Not a clear shape, but a muddy splatter.

Which makes what people tell me I am (or, more frequently, am not) looking for far more interesting, gives me license to listen carefully to friends’ constructive critiques of my crushes. Not because it’s likely to yield clues in my own search, but rather because it might give me a glimpse into theirs. Given the spattered mess of my own love life past, I seem to have inadvertently become a walking relationship Rorschach blotch.